Addressing Barriers to Care for Substance Use Disorder Pilot Study
Purpose
The Addressing Barriers to Care for Substance Use Disorder Pilot (ABC-SUD Pilot) was a randomized pilot study that preceded a larger trial. The ABC-SUD Pilot was a parallel group, cluster-randomized pilot feasibility trial, with clinicians (care coordinators) as the unit of randomization. This study was conducted in a mental health treatment access center within the Washington region of Kaiser Permanente. As part of usual care, patients contacted the mental health access center to speak to a "care coordinator" to obtain contact information for potential venues to obtain treatment for substance use disorder. The experimental intervention, Care Navigation, was evaluated for its potential to increase the utilization of substance use disorder treatment among patients who contacted the mental health treatment access center. The investigators note that Care Navigation was delivered by study "care navigators", who were distinct from the health system's care coordinators.
Conditions
- Drug Use Disorders
- Illicit Drug Use
- Alcohol-Related Disorders
Eligibility
- Eligible Ages
- Over 18 Years
- Eligible Genders
- All
- Accepts Healthy Volunteers
- No
Inclusion Criteria
- Conducts video or phone-based assessment and treatment planning visits in the mental health treatment access center - Has been employed for at least 1 month and has completed trainings related to their clinical role in the health system - Scheduled to conduct at least 3 assessments per day - Has consented to participate in the study. Clinician
Exclusion Criteria
- None Patient Inclusion Criteria (eligibility for analyses): - Visits an enrolled care coordinator during the patient eligibility period - ≥ 18 years of age at the time of the visit - Has an assessment and treatment planning visit for SUD with an enrolled care coordinator (this criterion was applied during the first period of the pilot, 7/9/2024-9/15/2024) - Has evidence of substance use as determined by the care coordinator (this criterion was applied during the second period of the pilot, 9/16/2024-11/27/2024) - Has an assessment and treatment planning visit for mental health treatment with an enrolled care coordinator (this criterion was applied during the second period of the pilot, 9/16/2024-11/27/2024) Patient Exclusion Criteria: - Patients who have requested through the health system to opt out of research contact or chart review - Patients who are not enrolled in Kaiser Permanente or Medicaid insurance (anticipated incomplete capture of covariate and/or outcome information)
Study Design
- Phase
- N/A
- Study Type
- Interventional
- Allocation
- Randomized
- Intervention Model
- Parallel Assignment
- Intervention Model Description
- Care coordinators were randomized to two parallel groups: usual care (UC; i.e., the comparator group) and usual care plus care navigation (UC + CN; i.e., the experimental group). All care coordinators continued offering substance use resources and treatment options to patients as usual. Clinicians randomized to UC + CN were able to offer and refer patients to a care navigator.
- Primary Purpose
- Health Services Research
- Masking
- Single (Outcomes Assessor)
- Masking Description
- All study outcomes are extracted from secondary data including electronic health record and healthcare claims databases
Arm Groups
| Arm | Description | Assigned Intervention |
|---|---|---|
|
Experimental Care Navigation (pilot) |
Mental health care coordinators offer and refer patients to a care navigator in addition to offering substance use resources and treatment options as usual. |
|
|
No Intervention Services as Usual (pilot) |
Mental health care coordinators offer substance use resources and treatment options to patients as usual |
|
Recruiting Locations
More Details
- NCT ID
- NCT06317987
- Status
- Active, not recruiting
- Sponsor
- Kaiser Permanente
Detailed Description
The ABC-SUD Pilot was conducted to evaluate feasibility of conducting a larger trial. Specific goals were to a) confirm patient eligibility criteria, b) confirm selection of the primary and secondary outcomes and the approach to measuring them using electronic health record data, c) confirm the feasibility and acceptability of randomization procedures, d) evaluate the feasibility of care navigation protocol delivery by care coordinators, e) evaluate feasibility of electronic health record templates to assist care coordinators when referring patients to care navigators. This pilot also helped refine study implementation needs and statistical analysis plans for the trial. The pilot's recruitment goal was to offer care navigation to patients until a total of 10 patients agreed to care navigation. The investigators conducted post-intervention quality improvement interviews with several enrolled patients to obtain feedback on intervention design to inform changes. To recruit care coordinators for the pilot, mental health treatment access center managers identified 4 care coordinators who volunteered to participate in piloting the care navigator intervention. To maximize the study sample for the larger trial, the pilot evaluated the feasibility of employing a "vanguard" randomization approach, which is a type of stratified randomization in which pilot (or vanguard) care coordinators are pre-randomized to begin piloting the intervention but then retain their randomization status for the subsequent trial. When using the vanguard method, the patient eligibility for the pilot period and trial period are distinct. Clinicians (care coordinators) were eligible if they conduct video or phone-based assessment and treatment planning visits in the mental health treatment access center, had been employed for at least 1 month, had completed trainings related to their clinical role in the health system, were scheduled to conduct at least 3 assessments per day, and consented to participate in the study. Over the course of the pilot, we changed patient eligibility criteria. During the first period of the pilot (07/09/2024 - 09/15/2024), the sample of patients eligible for the pilot analyses included individuals with a visit to an enrolled care coordinator who were ≥ 18 years of age and have a SUD assessment and treatment planning visit with a care coordinator. During the second period of the pilot (09/16/2024 - 11/27/2024), the sample of patients eligible for the pilot analyses included individuals with a visit to an enrolled care coordinator during the patient eligibility period who were ≥ 18 years of age, engaged in substance use, and had a mental health assessment and treatment planning visit with a care coordinator. We switched the eligibility criteria to allow us to determine the feasibility and appropriateness of offering care navigation to people with substance use who were seeking mental health treatment (instead of substance use treatment). Analyses follow an intent-to-treat principle whereby care coordinators are analyzed according to the intervention arm to which they were randomized regardless of the subsequent sequence of events. The patient eligibility period was defined as the period in which patients become eligible for the study (i.e., for inclusion in the analytic sample). This period is anticipated to start within 2 weeks of the clinician's randomization date (to allow for sufficient time for intervention coordinators to be trained). The investigators anticipated that approximately 40 patients would comprise the analytic sample.